· 5 min read
Differentiated Instruction for One Learner
How to adjust practice, pacing, or support for one learner while the group keeps moving, and how to plan the way back.

Most of the group is ready for rate problems. One learner isn't. The recipe calls for 2 cups of flour for every 3 cups of oats, and they keep writing the flour-to-oats ratio as 3 to 2, so every table they build is wrong from the first row.
The standard advice is to differentiate: adjust how learners reach a shared goal based on what each one needs. That can sound like writing a second lesson plan and then a third. For one learner, it's usually much smaller than that: one change, for a short stretch, for a reason you can explain.
Keep the goal where it is
Start with what stays the same. This learner is still working toward rates and unit rates, like everyone else.
Lowering the goal is tempting when someone falls behind. An easier worksheet or a separate track takes the pressure off for a day, but it makes rejoining the group harder, and the gap between their practice and the unit widens each week. Keep the destination and change how the learner gets there.
Pick one change that fits the evidence
There are only a few things to adjust, and each one fits a different problem.
- Time, when the learner understands the idea but works slowly or missed class. A later deadline or a shorter set of the same problems may be enough.
- Entry point, when an earlier idea is missing. More time on today's task won't help; they need the earlier step first.
- Representation, when the learner can reason in one form but not another. A ratio table, tape diagram, or double number line can show a relationship before symbols have to carry it.
- Guided practice, when the learner can follow an example but can't work alone yet.
The ratio learner needs a different entry point. They haven't connected the order of a ratio to the order of the quantities it describes, so more rate problems would mostly give them more practice reversing it. A short lesson on writing ratios from a description goes after the actual difficulty.
If you aren't sure which change fits, ask one more question first. "Which number goes with the flour?" can tell you more than another page of answers. Finding the missing step walks through locating where a learner's reasoning breaks down.
Put the support before the stuck step
Support that arrives after three failed assignments has to deal with frustration as well as the misunderstanding. Place it just before the task that depends on it, here the lesson on writing ratios and then the rate problems, so the learner meets the harder work with the missing piece in place.
The What Works Clearinghouse's guide to response to intervention in mathematics recommends explicit, systematic instruction during intervention and regular monitoring of learners who receive supplemental support. Its 2021 elementary intervention guide adds clear mathematical language and well-chosen representations. Both come down to knowing what the support is meant to teach and checking whether it did.
Decide in advance how the support ends
Without a planned exit, a short detour can turn into a permanent separate lane. Decide what evidence will bring the learner back. For the ratio learner, that might be writing three ratios correctly from new descriptions and explaining which quantity comes first. Once they can, they rejoin the group at the rate problems.
If they can't yet, you've still learned something. The gap may sit even earlier, or the representation may not be working for them. Make one more small adjustment and check again.
Tell the learner what changed and why
A learner who suddenly has different work will invent a reason for it, and it's rarely a kind one. Say it plainly: "Before the rate problems, you're doing one lesson on writing ratios in the right order. You've been mixing up which number goes first, and the rate problems depend on it."
That takes ten seconds. The learner hears what's hard, what the extra work is for, and that it leads back to what everyone else is doing.
How this works in PushPad
In PushPad, a learning path is the sequence of lesson pads you assign, and each pad covers one concept through vocabulary, an explanation, an example, an activity, practice, problems, and a quiz.
You can change one learner's path without affecting anyone else's: add a focused pad before the step where they're stuck, move a lesson, or extend or remove their deadline. Nothing changes until you confirm it, and the learner sees their updated path with the added pad in place. Each pad saves the learner's responses, so you can check the exit evidence you planned before they rejoin the group.
Common questions
What is the difference between differentiation and intervention?
Differentiation adjusts everyday instruction so more learners can reach the same goal. Intervention is more intensive, targeted support for learners who are well behind, usually with closer progress monitoring. A short support lesson for one learner sits between the two, which is why intervention habits like checking progress are worth borrowing.
Is differentiation the same as tracking?
No. Tracking places learners in fixed groups or levels, often for a whole year, with different goals for each group. Differentiation keeps the goal the same and adjusts the route for a short time, based on current evidence. A learner who gets extra support this week should be back on the shared path once their work shows they're ready.
Research behind this article
- What Works Clearinghouse: Response to intervention in mathematics, 2009. Recommendations for screening, explicit and systematic intervention, and monitoring the progress of learners who receive supplemental instruction.
- What Works Clearinghouse: Elementary mathematics intervention, 2021. Guidance on systematic instruction, mathematical language, and representations during intervention.
The ratio example illustrates the planning process. It is not drawn from a specific learner.
Put this into practice with lesson pads you control.