· 5 min read

Homework Learners Can Finish on Their Own

What research says about homework, and how to assign short, focused practice learners can complete at home without help.

In the early evening, a learner works on a tablet at a kitchen table, with a backpack hanging on the chair and warm lamp light.

Some learners finish their homework in ten minutes without learning anything new. Others spend an hour stuck on the second problem, with no one nearby who can help. Neither outcome is what you had in mind when you assigned it.

The research on homework is mixed, but it points toward one kind of assignment that tends to pay off: short, focused on something already taught, and possible to finish alone.

What the research says

Harris Cooper and colleagues reviewed homework studies from 1987 to 2003 and found generally positive links between homework and achievement. The links were stronger in grades 7 through 12 than in the elementary grades, which is a good reason to be especially selective about homework for younger learners.

How learners approach homework seems to matter more than how long it takes. In a study of secondary learners, Ulrich Trautwein found that the effort learners put into homework predicted achievement better than the time they spent on it. A learner who takes ninety minutes may be stuck rather than working harder.

Assign practice on what was taught

At home, no one is there to catch a misconception as it forms. A learner practicing an idea they don't understand yet is mostly practicing the mistake, so homework works best on material learners have already worked with in class.

Before assigning, ask whether most of the group could do the first two problems right now without you. If many couldn't, they need another round of guided practice in class first.

Keep it short and specific

Twenty focused minutes are usually worth more than an hour of drifting. Pick one skill and a handful of problems that show whether the learner can do it. If three answers would tell you what you need to know, five problems is plenty.

Specific directions help as well. "Finish the worksheet" only tells a learner when to stop. "Solve these five problems and circle the one you were least sure about" tells them what to pay attention to, and tells you where to start the next day.

Ask learners to recall, not reread

Rereading notes feels productive, but recalling the material does more for memory. Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke found that learners who practiced recalling a passage remembered more of it a week later than learners who spent the same time rereading it.

For homework, that can mean a few questions answered from memory, a short explanation in the learner's own words, or a mix of problems from this week and last.

Plan for the learner who gets stuck

Some learners will get stuck however carefully you plan, so decide ahead of time what they should do: try one similar problem, write down the step where they got lost, or send you a question. "I got stuck on step two because I didn't know which number to divide by" is far more useful to you than a blank page, and writing it keeps the learner thinking about the problem.

Then look at what comes back. If homework is never checked, learners conclude it doesn't count. A quick look at the hardest problem, or at the one they circled, is enough to show that it does.

At-home practice in PushPad

PushPad runs in a web browser, so a lesson pad works on whatever phone, tablet, or computer a learner has at home. Each pad focuses on one concept, and every section has Read aloud for learners who need to hear the text.

Deadlines on assignments are optional, and you can extend or remove one for an individual learner. You can follow each learner's progress on their assignments, and their responses are saved for you to review. Learners can also send you a message when they're stuck.

Common questions

How much homework should learners get?

A widely cited guideline, endorsed by the National PTA and the National Education Association, is about ten minutes per night per grade level. Research suggests the focus and quality of homework matter more than the minutes, especially in the elementary grades.

How can homework be differentiated?

Keep the skill the same and vary the starting point. A learner still building the skill gets problems close to the class examples, while a learner who is secure gets a few mixed or harder ones. Avoid making extra work the only difference, which tends to feel like a penalty. Differentiated instruction for one learner covers the broader approach.


Research behind this article

The examples illustrate the teaching process. They are not drawn from specific learners.

Put this into practice with lesson pads you control.

Get started
Back to blog